Philadelphia’s City Council is at odds with the Office of Property Assessment (OPA) following a recent hearing regarding the agency’s performance. Mayor Cherelle L. Parker’s Philadelphia Home Assessment Bias Task Force released a report suggesting improvements in OPA’s operations, but City Council members are pushing for a freeze on property assessments instead of the recommended two- to three-year reassessment cycle.
City Council Questions OPA’s Reassessment Plans
During the hearing, Councilmember Jamie Gauthier emphasized the need to prioritize equity alongside reassessments, asking OPA chief James Aros if he would consider halting reassessments until further progress is made. Aros declined to commit to a pause, stating that delaying assessments would hinder improvement efforts.
Councilmember Quetcy Lozada expressed frustration with Aros’s responses, highlighting ongoing issues with the assessment process that have persisted since reforms were called for in 2019. The task force’s report indicated that while OPA’s performance has improved, significant disparities remain, particularly in predominantly Black and Latino neighborhoods, where property valuations have surged by up to 50%.
Task Force Recommendations and OPA’s Response
Monty Wilson, a member of the task force and senior attorney with Community Legal Services, acknowledged OPA’s progress but noted that the agency still makes numerous errors across nearly 600,000 properties. He suggested extending the window for property owners to challenge assessments, which currently closes in early October, to allow for more time to contest significant increases in property taxes.
Aros mentioned that OPA is seeking improved data for future evaluations and plans to collaborate with City Council members to conduct in-person inspections in specific neighborhoods. The task force also recommended an independent review of OPA’s practices to identify lingering disparities and develop fairer assessment approaches.
Despite the task force’s findings, Council members have not yet decided on their next steps, as they are still reviewing the report issued on Friday. Aros indicated that the hearing served as the starting point for further discussions on property assessment reform.
Background on Philadelphia’s Property Assessment Issues
The Office of Property Assessment in Philadelphia has faced criticism for its handling of real estate assessments, particularly regarding the fairness and transparency of the process. The agency’s assessments have often resulted in disproportionately high tax burdens on lower-income neighborhoods, leading to calls for reform from various stakeholders, including city officials and community advocates.
As discussions continue, the City Council is expected to deliberate on the task force’s recommendations and determine how best to address the ongoing challenges in property assessments.




